Evaluating My 2016 Young WR Model Performance
Get a free NFL subscription for 3 days.
Prior to the 2016 season I created a model that tried to predict PPR production on a per-game basis for young wide receivers, which I defined as WRs in their first four years in the league. This article is going to break down the model results. For all the data the models were built from, as well as the 2016 model projections themselves, refer to the linked article.
In this model, age was more important than market share (on a scaled basis). This model produced a backtested R-squared value of only 0.298 with a RMSE of 3.357 on 318 observations. Projecting rookies is really hard.
This model has a backtested R-squared of 0.514 with a RMSE of 3.451.
The term for SEAS dropped off. Also, in a player’s second year, we should give slightly more weight to his college market share than his draft age. Prior year PPR points per game and rookie year playing time are the most significant factors.
This model produced a backtested R-squared of 0.513 and an RMSE of 3.641. Notice the AGE.Z term has dropped off completely, meaning by a receiver’s third year in the NFL we shouldn’t even factor in draft age. Draft position, NFL production, and collegiate production tell the whole story.
The R-squared for this model is 0.467 and the RMSE is 3.748. In this model model, any notion of draft position, age, and college production has dropped off. This is the point in a receiver’s career at which he has fully established (or failed to establish) himself as an NFL receiver.
Reviewing the ModelsFirst I’m going to start with a brief review of the models. I created a separate model for each of the first four seasons of an NFL receiver’s career. The factors I looked at included:
- Year (SEAS)
- Logarithm of draft position (L.DPOS)
- Draft age z-score (AGE.Z)1
- Final year collegiate market share z-score (MS.Z)
- PPR points per game the prior year (PPR.N)
- Games played the prior year (GMS.N)
Rookie ModelThe rookie year model had the following significant predictors:
Second Year ModelHere’s the model for second year receivers:
Third Year Model
Fourth Year Model