Odell Beckham, Mike Evans, and the RotoViz Rookie Composite Rankings


The rankings in the table below are the result of 15 RotoViz writers organizing the 2014 rookie class based on where they would draft them in dynasty rookie drafts. We’ve written a lot of articles and pored over these rookies with an obsession that would probably weird out even the creeps that go stare at horses in the paddock before making a $2 bet1. If you have a question as to why a player was ranked where they were, you have a few options. You might try the sidebar search and look for articles about that player. You can also post a comment and we’ll try to get to it within reason. In the past we’ve highlighted articles that formed our thinking but in this case it might be 3 or 4 articles per player multiplied by 30-40 players that we’ve covered, so it didn’t seem feasible. For primers on the individual positions you can check out our pre-draft positional rankings, which can be found at this page.

Using the rankings of each writer, and applying a simple scoring system that rewards a player for more positive ranks, we can also get tiers out of this exercise. The following graph shows rough tiers based on using the x axis as the Composite Rank, and the y axis as the Composite Score.

I’m sure the various writers will be chiming in over the next few days to note where the Wisdom of the Crowd has screwed up these ranks, but until then, I give you the Composite Rookie Rankings:

The rankers are: FD = Fantasy Douche, DM = Davis Mattek, JM2 = Jake Myers, MF = Matthew Freedman, JW = Justin Winn, SS = Shawn Siegele, JMo = Jon Moore, SS2 = Scott Smith, RL = Ryan Lessard, JT = James Todd, RE = Ross Eagles, WTF = Whisky Tango Foxtrot, ZD = Zach Dietz, BF = Bryan Fontaine, CR = the Composite Ranking

Mike Evans2211121112411211
S. Watkins1454714434222322
J. Matthews31332113241635143
Brandin Cooks6342555355363734
Bishop Sankey5765332926146475
Davante Adams7826488587754666
Allen Robinson85716131018763588587
Eric Ebron116101510478989971258
A. Seferian-Jenkins1211121499116101014121211109
Johnny Manziel14141612671017141481413151210
Jeremy Hill1512278196611715101111161811
Cody Latimer1615111012222215121211101091512
K. Benjamin4108718231716162116714131413
Donte Moncrief20161321222191220111513981714
Marqise Lee918152514122322179181515101315
O. Beckham Jr.10191413211312131523241618241116
Jace Amaro1391820171919101819121922212117
Teddy Bridgewater2217261181721231113171721142018
Terrance West18231718161613202116132017192619
Carlos Hyde17139935141621192431222420920
Blake Bortles24222022111520141322212123222221
Andre Williams26212217151814272218191816183222
Tre Mason25273024242027182626202325171623
Jarvis Landry23291923292524412345232619232324
Paul Richardson21262519202625282446332832251925
Jerick McKinnon19202828262415192738482426322926
Ka'Deem Carey27282129363129252527272534292827
Devonta Freeman30313540412728354817223627282728
Charles Sims33304926423031343233373338312429
Tyler Gaffney29413732233541383130302952334030
Josh Huff31343634993432312929363035383531
Martavis Bryant41474199472934522820293120262532
Jeff Janis40253236463635423434353242353333
L. Seastrunk34242347593244293332462746273834
Lorenzo Taliaferro28322930342826363054323753465835
Isaiah Crowell42362427524137585625394354303136
Quincy Enunwa38384099483733455131283441364337
Derek Carr37374746284253493950344229343738
Dri Archer32334533373938403757534039524539
James White35445244403330555842434830433940
Storm Johnson36403331255555993541523547475341
John Brown39565735539936334237265640993442
Michael Campanaro44394499315159303843405248519943
Albert Wilson45434648304547604735254755999944
C.J. Fiedorowicz52996099605940244640454128483645
Zach Mettenberger48993999395645594036494444404446
Jimmy Garoppolo47423841994352995349994531554647
Troy Niklas99995099995799264539479937533048
Damien Williams49469937583848993699515199379949
David Fluellen46995139504656535499443899449950
Jared Abbrederis51494349544749514999995359495451
Marion Grice99459943515351395755504956595552
Joe Don Duncan43999938279960329999993999999953
Bruce Ellington53509999329946994499999933995254
Robert Herron99514299996099434352429960994155
Colt Lyerla54453442999942994199999999995656
De'Anthony Thomas50999999574039465099565445999957
Tim Cornett55999955335299569958389999399958
Aaron Murray99999999384454999999994636565159
A.C. Leonard60994845999950575544419999996060
Brandon Coleman99995499999958995228555057995061
Richard Rodgers99999999439999479947999951574262
Tom Savage99999999455099996099995799424863
TJ Jones56993156994999999959996099999964
David Fales99485399565899999999999950509965
Henry Josey99549999494899999999605599999966
Crockett Gillmore99999999999999449999999943999967
Darrin Reaves99999953999999379960999999609968
Jalen Saunders99999999999943999999999999994769
Antonio Andrews99999954995499999999999999459970
Logan Thomas58999999999957995999999999419971
Chandler Jones99539950999999549999999999999972
Shaquelle Evans99995899559999999999995949995973
A.J. McCarron99999999449999999999999999549974
Jeremy Gallon99999999999999509953999999995775
Alex Neutz99555557999999999999599999999976
Devin Street99995699999999999999999999994977
Rob Blanchflower99999999999999489999589999999978
Ryan Grant99999999999999999951999958999979
Brett Smith99999999999999999948999999999980
Rajion Neal99999951999999999999999999999981

Subscribe for a constant stream of league-beating articles available only with a Premium Pass.

  1. The creeps make the bet, not the horses.  (back)
By RotoViz Staff | @rotoviz | Archive

No Comment

Leave a reply