For the past 4 weeks I’ve done Tuesday rundowns of the backfield situations for lots of NFL teams. I’m doing the same thing this week. Also, since I’m not entirely omniscient, check out RotoViz’s Buy Low Machine and RB GLSP Projections. Here we go.
With Stevan Ridley inactive, LeGarrette Blount drew the start and did what he did in Tampa Bay: fumble and fail to impress on short-yardage carries. Meanwhile, Brandon Bolden, as the most versatile Pats RB currently healthy, managed 12.4 PPR pts with six catches. I’m not saying that Bolden is a season-savior, but as long as Shane Vereen is on the short-term IR, Brandon Bolden is my favorite Patriots RB. Stevan Ridley can’t be discounted, but Blount is destroying Ridley’s value. For now, Bolden is a flexible bye-week option with upside in PPR leagues. The other two guys just make me sad.
I’m not bothered by BenJarvus Green-Ellis (against his former team) out-carrying Giovani Bernard. Gio’s fumble, though, bothers me. Still, I prefer “Mini McCoy” to BJGE, and he’s a strong PPR flex with upside. Franky, given his QB’s arm limitations, Gio could get 5 checkdown catches per game with ease. He’s not going to finish each week as a top-20 RB, but he’s a weekly starter.
Pierre Thomas, you’re an evil man. You’re not the guy who caught 9 passes for 55 yards and 2 TDs. You’re the guy who rushed 19 times for 36 yards. You’re Mark Ingram’s slightly superior doppelganger. Speaking of whom, I should point this out: Jed Collins had 4 receptions in Week 5. Ingram has zero on the season. Ingram’s a fantasy nightmare. Darren Sproles? You’re not thrilled with his 7.1 PPR pts in Week 5, but he’s a flex option. You put up with his tolerable weeks because he gives you 30-pt weeks on occasion. But you just hate seeing one of those 30-pt weeks go to Thomas—especially if you also roster both guys and benched Thomas in Week 5.
Maybe the player most important to Detroit’s running game is Calvin Johnson. In Week 5, Joique Bell played like a PPR flex option. That’s what he is, and we like him. Reggie Bush also played like a PPR flex option. That’s not what he is, but I still like him anyway.
I’ll say what I’ve been saying all along. Eddie Lacy has top-10 potential. Johnathan Franklin and James Starks? I admit that there’s a place in the NFL and the fantasy universe for guys like them. It’s called the bench and the waiver wire.
I’m glad you don’t need me to tell you that Jamaal Charles is awesome.
I guess Marshawn Lynch should be owned in almost all leagues.
In my Week 2 report I said this: “I know he’s supposed to be great, but maybe Trent Richardson isn’t that good. Maybe he’s just a bigger-bodied Mark Ingram-esque talent on a team with no other RBs. That’s really what he was last year, despite his top-10 positional finish.” I haven’t seen anything in 2013 to make me think I’m wrong. He’s a solid starter from here on out, but he’ll rely on volume and TDs. And he’s splitting time with Donald Brown. In Week 5, he got the volume but not the TDs, and the result was sub-Donald. If you want, tell yourself with each passing week that T-Rich is a good runner who hasn’t hit his stride yet. Just realize that if you’re saying that in Week 5 next year, you’ll have a glorified Ingram on your hands. No one wants that.
Maurice Jones-Drew: You’ve been a good and faithful servant, Severus, but only I can live forever. In other words, I still don’t believe. Jordan Todman: I think I believe. I think I believe.
Ray Rice is a guy you normally want not to bench.
David Wilson got the TD but he still disappointed in his limited action before exiting the game with a neck injury. Apparently his exit was precautionary, but I don’t take neck injuries lightly. In other words, I can envision a scenario in which someone other than Wilson and the deceased Brandon Jacobs gets carries for the Giants. That guy could be the returning Andre Brown (at some point), but I think he could also be Michael Cox. When a group of RBs plays this bad, eventually the guy at the bottom of the depth chart gets a shot. I bet that Cox—the next late-round Giants stud RB and a potential 2013 Wire Waiver Wonder—will get an opportunity. Cox isn’t rosterable in redraft leagues. In deep dynasty leagues? Yes. All that’s between him and the #2 job is Brandon Jacobs and eventually Andre Brown. That’s like saying that all that’s between Beatrix and freedom is a plywood coffin and six feet of dirt. Eventually, a breakout will occur.
Week 5, LeSean McCoy, 92 total yards, 6 receptions, 1 TD: an utterly disappointing and totally matchup-proof performance. McCoy may be the best RB of 2013—but Bryce Brown is the most important man not starting for Chip Kelly. Get him on your team. Get him on your team. Get him on your team. And I don’t hate Chris Polk, either.
Rashard Mendenhall looked Reshardy with his bad yardage and “whatever TD” in Week 5, but I don’t trust Andre Ellington because of his size. (I hate small RBs.) Still, if you want Ellington as a cheap throw-in component of a trade, I won’t blame you. He has the upside of a Rashard injury. But as for me and my house, we will avoid this backfield.
We’ve reached that point in the season. If you have Knowshon Moreno, I guess you’re starting him. He could be the king of the 2013 flexes. He could also destroy your season one week at a time.
You know what to do.
Frank Gore thanks you for keeping the faith.
Fred Jackson wants to know what you were thinking when you passed on him in Rounds 5-10. He’s taking it personally. I’ve said before that F-Jax has top-10 potential if C.J. Spiller is injured. F-Jax is imminently flexible in all formats. C.J. Spiller? He’s pretty good too.
I prefer Jim Brown.
Week 5 wasn’t pretty, but Danny Woodhead was again the best RB for the Chargers. We like him. He’s like Shane Vereen, except not injured. He’ll maintain value because he’s useful in the passing game. Speaking of which, for at least Weeks 1-5, I was right.
When I said in this piece that Jacquizz Rodgers might not be horrible handcuff, random performances like Rodgers’ 2-TD outburst in Week 5 are what I had in mind. And when I said that Jason Snelling could be better than just a desperation play, TD-reliant performances like Snelling’s Week 5 . . . well, not really, but you get the idea.
I once interviewed for a book project a guy who repeatedly used this construction: “It made me want to vomit. It made me want to vomit on my vomit”—as in, “That band sucked so much it made me want to vomit. It made me want to vomit on my vomit.” Something about the Jets RBs in Week 5 brought that guy to mind. Maybe it’s the green in their uniforms.
Le’Veon Bell: I miss your musk. It’ll be good to have you back in Week 6.
Interested in WRs? Here’s my Week 5 WR Report.