DynastyFootball

Geno Smith: Browning Nagle or Peyton Manning?

Photo by Greg Cooper

Photo by Greg Cooper

The first four games of Geno Smith’s career have been…interesting. He leads the league in turnovers (tied with Eli Manning) with 11, gets a lot of poor press reviews, and has created his own, new and improved butt fumble. Is he just another Jets’ folly? Another Mark Sanchez? Or, possibly worse, Browning Nagle?  
Here’s a Smith-Nagle comparison after four starts. Obviously, it’s not a flattering measure for Smith:
BROWNING NAGLE VS. GENO SMITH: FIRST FOUR GAMES
Quarterback Comp/Att Pct. TD INT Yds. Rating
Nagle 69/138 50.0 4 4 878 67.8
Smith 78/136 57.4 4 8 1,090 68.6
  I’m here to say it’s too early to pass judgment. In fact, in dynasty formats, I think he’s worth acquiring if his current owner is disillusioned by his inconsistency and turnovers. Nothing has happened that should discount his solid pre-draft projections, and he could be better than we think. Here’s why.

Subscribe to the best value in fantasy sports

You're all out of free reads for now and subscribing is the only way to make sure you don't ever miss an article.

By James Todd | @spidr2ybanana | Archive

No Comment

Leave a reply